High court rules against Puerto Rico in debt case
The United States Supreme Court ruled Monday that Puerto Rico can't restructure more than US$20 billion in public debt as it tries to overcome a decade-long economic crisis.
The 5-2 ruling said that federal bankruptcy law bars Puerto Rico from enacting its own law to restructure the debt of its financially ailing public utilities. The decision means the US territory must wait for Congress to pass debt-relief legislation that would address its fiscal woes.
Puerto Rico lawmakers passed the law in 2014 to help cash-strapped utilities meet obligations to bondholders and creditors. Puerto Rico argued that it could enact its own measures since the island is precluded from using bankruptcy law. But the Supreme Court upheld lower court rulings that struck down the law. The commonwealth is mired in recession and cannot pay US$72 billion in public debt.
Writing for the court, Justice Clarence Thomas said the plain text of the law bars Puerto Rico from enacting its own municipal bankruptcy schemes. He said Congress "would have said so" if it didn't want the exclusion to apply to the island.
"Congress does not, one might say, hide elephants in mouse holes," Thomas said.
The case has diminished in importance since Congress began considering legislation that would create a new control board to manage the territory's finances and allow the board to supervise some court-ordered debt restructuring. Help for the debt-stricken territory may be just weeks after the House voted Friday to approve the bill.
Lawmakers had hoped to pass the measure before May 1, when Puerto Rico defaulted on US$370 million in bond payments. GOP leaders are now focusing on a July 1 deadline, when around US$2 billion in principle and interest payments come due.
A high court ruling in Puerto Rico's favour would have given the island more leverage to negotiate with creditors, even as Congress moves closer to passing debt-relief legislation.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, whose parents were born in Puerto Rico, filed a dissent that was joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. She said preventing the island from passing its own debt restructuring laws "means that a government is left powerless and with no legal process to help its 3.5 million citizens".
"Congress could step in to resolve Puerto Rico's crisis," Sotomayor said. "But, in the interim, the government should not have to wait for possible congressional action to avert the consequences of unreliable electricity, transportation and safe water."
The issue before the high court was how to interpret a 1984 amendment to the nation's federal bankruptcy laws. The law allows states to let their cities and utilities seek bankruptcy relief, but it specifically excludes Puerto Rico a territory from doing so.
Puerto Rico lawmakers passed their own version of bankruptcy laws in 2014 to help the island's utilities meet obligations to bondholders and creditors.
But a federal district court agreed with creditors including Blue Mountain Capital Management Oppenheimer Funds Inc and Franklin Advisers Inc in ruling that the local measure is not allowed under federal bankruptcy law. The 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals agreed.
Puerto Rico's representative in Congress, Pedro Pierluisi, said the ruling makes it "essential" for Congress to pass legislation to help lift the island out of its economic crisis.
Matthew McGill, a lawyer who represented BlueMountain Capital Management, said the company looks forward to "working collaboratively" with Puerto Rico's electric utility to restructure the debt.
The pending bill in Congress contains language that would prevent Puerto Rico from using its own laws to restructure public debt.
The island has been under a state of emergency and many businesses have closed, schools have lacked sufficient resources like electricity, and some hospitals are limiting treatment.
Puerto Rico's governor says the island can't pay the bonds without cutting essential services.
Only seven justices heard the case. Justice Antonin Scalia died in February and Justice Samuel Alito recused himself.
Alito owns shares in a tax-free fund that invests in Puerto Rican bonds and is involved in the case.