Carolyn Cooper | Chanting down greedy hoteliers
Last week's column, 'No Beach For Local Tourists', touched a very sensitive nerve. I got so many emails from both Jamaicans and other Caribbean citizens who are very concerned about the way in which hoteliers dominate the conversation about public access to our beaches.
Diana McCaulay, CEO of the Jamaica Environment Trust (JET), highlights this troubling issue of special interests in her excellent article, 'The Problem of Beach Exclusion', published in The Gleaner on Wednesday, January 11: "In 1997, the NRCA [National Resources Conservation Authority] began work on a beach policy to address issues surrounding public access and a Green Paper was drafted which proposed open access. There was immediate pushback from the tourism industry".
Of course, there was pushback! Hoteliers don't want open access to beaches because this will reduce their control of valuable resources. Their all-exclusive hotels would become much too inclusive for their liking. They want to erect barbed wire fences, stretching into the sea, to keep out the locals.
We cannot sit back passively and allow our beaches to be captured by greedy hoteliers, irresponsible politicians and all those who benefit from the current state of affairs. We have to take action. We, Jamaicans, like to think of ourselves as militant. We boast about our Ashanti warrior heritage. But we don't always put up a fight for important causes. We need to follow the example of our uncompromising Caribbean neighbours who refuse to be shut out of their beaches.
I got an inspiring email from Antigua. Here's an excerpt. I've deleted the name of the hotelier: "A few years ago, [a Jamaican hotelier] tried to get the Government of Antigua and Barbuda to 'allow' him to turn one of our most visited and, by far, favourite beaches - among locals and visitors - into a private enclave for his guests. The protests from the locals and nearby residents were not only unrelenting, but in your face. Some of the protests even went viral. He eventually backed away and the Government did not have to intervene ... the people with the power had spoken".
One of the most outspoken warriors in the fight to keep Caribbean beaches out of the grasp of hoteliers is the Barbadian calypsonian The Mighty Gabby. His 1982 calypso, Jack, was a classic piece of throw word confronting Jack Dear, chairman of the Barbados Tourist Board. Dear, who was certainly not dearly beloved, had declared that hotel owners had the right to develop their property up to the waterfront of the island's beaches.
This is how Gabby launched his counterattack:
"I grow up bathing in seawater
But nowadays dat is bare horror
If I only venture down by the shore
Police telling me Ah can't bathe no more
Cause Jack don't want me to bathe on my beach
Jack tell dem to keep me out of reach
Jack tell dem I will never make the grade
Strength and security build barricade
Da can't happen here in this country
I want Jack to know dat di beach belong to we
Da can't happen here over my dead body
Tell Jack dat I say dat di beach belong to we".
Gabby knows that the barricades are all about the tourist dollar. And he's not prepared to sell his birthright:
"Tourism vital, I can't deny
But can't mean more than I and I
My navel string bury right here
But a tourist one could be anywhere
Yet Jack don't want me to bathe on my beach".
Gabby's use of "I and I" is an assertion of Rastafari consciousness. It empowers him to chant down the forces of oppression.
BIG UP WI BEACH
Tourism is now vital to our economies across the Caribbean. But we have to find a way to balance the requirements of the tourist industry and the needs of citizens. We can't just fence in tourists and fence out locals. Many hoteliers assume that their property is like a cruise ship. And the ship is the destination. But some tourists actually want to escape the all-exclusive prison. They want to meet the people outside the barricades.
Diana McCaulay shows us the way forward: "It is true that harassment is a problem for the tourist industry - or indeed for any visitor to a Jamaican beach. But the response cannot be exclusion. The response has to be commitment to a set of articulated principles - frequent access points; provision of well-managed public beaches, including the requirement for behaviour by beach users that does not present a nuisance or threat to others or to the beach itself".
This week, the Jamaica Environment Trust launches 'Big Up Wi Beach' on Facebook. It's an open forum for debate on beach access and related issues such as beach erosion. Readers are invited to post images of their favourite beaches and to write about their memories of great beach outings.
JET is also developing a petition to the Government advocating a definitive policy on beach access for all Jamaicans. I trust that the Urban Development Corporation will support the petition. I won't hold my breath. I still haven't gotten an answer to my email to the director of corporate communications about access to Pearly Beach. And I hope Jamaican musicians will create a song in support of the campaign. Like Gabby, they simply must chant down greedy hoteliers.