Sat | Nov 17, 2018

Defence lawyers criticise Egypt gay raid trial

Published:Monday | January 5, 2015 | 12:00 AM
In this Thursday, December 11, 2014 photo, an Egyptian lesbian poses for a photograph in Cairo, Egypt. Egypts gay community is going deeper underground in fear after police arrest dozens of men at a Cairo bathhouse in a raid that was then featured on a lurid TV tabloid programme, stirring up public panic over debauchery. Egypts government is cracking down on gays, activists say, to promote its credentials as protectors of public morals. -AP

CAIRO (AP):Defence lawyers for 26 men arrested in a televised raid by police looking for gays at an Egyptian bathhouse criticised the prosecutions case yesterday, saying it is based on a faulty investigation and only one police officers testimony.

The raid was part of an ongoing crackdown on gays in Egypt, described by activists as the worst in more than a decade. While consensual gay and lesbian relationships are not specifically outlawed in Egypt, there is a societal taboo against same-sex couples.

A private TV stations crew filmed the mens arrest, saying it tipped off police to a bathhouse "hosting men sex orgies". The televised raid outraged activists.

One lawyer representing 14 of the men, Islam Khalifa, told the court yesterday that the defendants suffered 'psychological duress' from the publicised arrests, which defamed and endangered both them and their families in conservative Egypt. He said having the television crew there violated the mens right to privacy and Egypt's constitution.

Medical examinations

Of the 26 men, 21 have undergone medical examinations to see if they had had anal sex. Three of the men had trauma that required further examination, defence lawyer Tarek al-Awadi said.

The men face charges including debauchery and performing indecent public acts. Such vague terms can apply to prostitution or even public display of affection.

Their trial began December 21. Yesterday, the men stood in a small cage in the court, some with hoodies covering their face. Two wept in front of journalists, who were not allowed to approach them.

Family members were not allowed to attend the session, apparently to avoid outbursts as lawyers discussed details of the case. Angry family members largely refused to speak to the journalists gathered there, accusing them of trying to slander their relatives.

"We are innocent! We were scandalised! No one in our family is gay!" one screamed.

As the defendants left the courtroom, one relative chanted "Raise your heads up high. Acquittals, God willing."

Once in a security vehicle to return to jail, family members shouted: "You are men! You are men!"

The trial will resume today.