Thu | Oct 1, 2020

UK Parliament case opens at Supreme Court as Brexit nears

Published:Tuesday | September 17, 2019 | 9:18 AM
Protesters hold banners outside the Supreme Court in London, Tuesday September 17, 2019. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham)

LONDON (AP) — A lawyer urged Britain’s Supreme Court on Tuesday to rule that Prime Minister Boris Johnson illegally suspended Parliament just weeks before the country is due to leave the European Union for the “improper purpose” of dodging scrutiny of his Brexit plans.

The country’s highest court is sitting to resolve a case that pits the powers of elected lawmakers against those of the executive in a struggle to control the course of Brexit.

Johnson sent lawmakers home on Sept. 9 until Oct. 14, which is barely two weeks before the scheduled October 31 Brexit day.

The prime minister says Britain must leave the EU at the end of next month, with or without a divorce deal.

But many lawmakers believe a no-deal Brexit would be economically devastating and socially destabilising, and are determined to thwart him.

Lawyer David Pannick, who represents one of the campaigners challenging the government, told 11 Supreme Court judges that Johnson had improperly suspended the legislature “to silence Parliament ... because he sees Parliament as an obstacle to the furtherance of his political aims.”

The court will hear from government lawyers later in the day.

Johnson says the suspension is routine and will allow his government to launch its domestic agenda with a new session of Parliament.

But the decision outraged many lawmakers, who say it’s designed to prevent them from challenging Johnson’s push for Brexit in October “do or die.”

The suspension sparked legal challenges, to which lower courts have given contradictory rulings.

England’s High Court said the suspension was a political rather than legal matter, but Scottish court judges ruled last week that Johnson acted illegally “to avoid democratic scrutiny.”

The Supreme Court is being asked to decide who was right, in a case scheduled to last up to three days.

It is considering two questions: Is this a matter for the courts; and, if so, did the government break the law?

We want to hear from you! Send us a message on WhatsApp at 1-876-499-0169, email us at or