Thu | May 5, 2016

Our Government has AIDS - Failure to implement, execute is symptom of disease

Published:Sunday | November 25, 2012 | 12:00 AM
Dr Adrian Stokes has repeatedly bemoaned Jamaica's competitive disadvantages.
Bobby Montague hasn't presented an iota of data on consultancy salaries.

Robert Wynter, Contributor

Were St Paul of Tarsus alive today and giving advice to Jamaicans at this point in our history, I suggest he would have modified his famous letter to the Corinthians to read: "If I articulate my plans in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not execute, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of visioning and can fathom all opportunities and threats, and if I have faith that Jamaica can be the place of choice to live, work, raise families and do business, but do not execute, I am nothing. If I love the poor and sacrifice my body to hard work that I may boast, but do not execute, I gain nothing."

Audley Shaw's recent revelation that only $400 million will be available when the International Monetary Fund's (IMF) gestation period is finally over has sent jitters throughout the business sector, as everyone is expecting a windfall with the signing of an agreement. This has been the mood ever since Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller reportedly told a Bloomberg reporter at the investment conference that Jamaica would do well with a "Greek-style bailout". (Bloomberg later retracted the statement.)

While it is true that the IMF agreement will also be a stamp of approval to borrow from multilaterals and others licking their chops to lend us money, the resulting mounting debt will go counter to the wishes of Finance Minister Peter Phillips to significantly reduce Jamaica's debt stock. Our only hope, it seems, is to make sure that whatever loans we receive will add value of greater proportions than the interest charged.

Executing needs patience. Executors must be kind to all, they ought not to envy, they ought not to boast, and they ought not to be proud. They must not dishonour critics, they must not be self-seeking, they must not be easily angered by those who oppose them; they need not dwell on or defend their wrongdoings. They must not delight in evil, but rejoice in truth. Executors must always protect, always trust, always give hope, and always persevere.


Under successive administrations, Jamaica's record of extracting value from loans has been dismal. This has been borne out in the estimated average 40 per cent achievement of the objectives under the programmes accompanying our bilateral and multilateral loans. The fundamental reason has been our governments' (cabinets', ministries', departments' and agencies') affliction with acquired implementation deficiency syndrome, or AIDS. In fact, others may go further to say we have AEDS (acquired execution deficiency
syndrome), as there is a subtle yet very important distinction between
implementation and execution. The former focuses on actions, while the
latter focuses on results or performance

Executors may fail at first, but with a focus
on the vision and with perseverance, they will succeed. But where there
are naysayers and critics, they will cease; where there are forked
tongues, they will be stilled; where there is misguided knowledge, it
will pass away.

Audley Shaw's recent broadside of the
Government's affliction with AEDS, while founded, suggested that he and
his administration were not so afflicted. I find it very hard to
understand Mr Shaw's declaration that he had commenced the
implementation of the public-sector reform

This is far from reality, as although Bruce
Golding's Cabinet accepted the Public Sector Transformation Unit's
recommendations to restructure government for greater levels of
effectiveness and efficiency, the JLP gave it only lip service, while
fully afflicted with AEDS. This has carried over to this administration
in no uncertain fashion.


Not to be outdone, Senator Bobby Montague
delivered an extremely emotional presentation in the Upper House on
November 9, for which he earned, as fellow senator, Lambert Brown put
it, the privilege to buy a couple rounds of drinks. Senator Montague
suggested that the Government fire all consultants and use the savings
to fund the Students' Loan Bureau (SLB).

Year in, year
out, we get a constant diet from opposition parliamentarians and
supporters that somehow we are wasting valuable resources on
consultants. While some consultants are usually retired
parliamentarians, unsuccessful candidates or other party functionaries,
the accusations are blanket statements without the concomitant data to
back up said accusations.

With the consultants being
paid roughly $200 million per year, not significantly different than
when Senator Montague was a Cabinet minister, it boggles the mind why
the goodly senator has failed to suggest using some of the $150-billion
public-sector wage bill for the SLB. Senator Montague can, therefore, be
characterised as being penny wise and pound foolish in opposition, as
he, too, was afflicted with AEDS while in

For we know, in part, and we execute, in
part; but when completeness comes, what is in part disappears. When I
was a child, I talked liked a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned
like a child, I planned like a child. When I became a man, I put away
the ways of childhood behind me.


In a recent discussion hosted by Garfield
Burford on CVM, panellists had differing views on the cause of our
economic challenges, the way forward, and the performance of Government
in addressing these challenges. Government senator Lambert Brown, who in
a previous life criticised the Government for its affliction with AEDS
(my interpretation), now seems quite prepared to accept and defend his
Government's affliction.

Senator Brown suggests there
is genuine hope, that the prime minister has articulated an overall
vision (which he never shared), and that the Government is doing little
things here and little things there.

Economist Ralston
Hyman points to the current account deficit and suggests that high
energy, food and manufactured items' import costs are the main culprits.
Mr Hyman failed to mention the other side of the current account
equation, which includes the export of goods and

The fact is that we need energy and food,
and at this time it is much easier to import than to produce ourselves.
What we need to do is find a way to earn enough to pay for the imported
energy and food. This is not happening because we are afflicted with

Financial analyst Dr Adrian Stokes was spot on
when he said the country's low competitiveness was the problem. However,
while Dr Stokes correctly pointed to the uncompetitive firms, he failed
to mention the uncompetitive government afflicted with

For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror;
soon we shall see face to face. Now we know, in part; soon we shall
know fully, even as we are fully known. And now these three remain:
visioning, planning and execution. But the greatest of these is

Robert Wynter is the managing director of
Strategic Alignment Limited, which facilitates organisational
transformation and leadership development. Comments are welcome at and