Thu | Oct 6, 2022

Americans sentenced in Panama for 5 murders

Published:Monday | August 14, 2017 | 3:33 PM
In July 2010, American William Dathan Holbert and wife Laura Reese are escorted off a police vehicle during their extradition to Panama in Managua, Nicaragua.


United States citizen William Dathan Holbert was sentenced to 47 years in prison by a court in Panama for robbing and killing five other Americans in a Caribbean tourist destination, authorities said yesterday.

Holbert's ex-wife, Laura Reese, was sentenced to 26 years for her role.

Authorities said Holbert admitted killing five people between 2007 and 2010 in Bocas del Toro province in order to steal their property.

Appeal likely

Holbert's lawyer, Claudia Alvarado, suggested that an appeal was likely.

Holbert and Reese were arrested while trying to enter Nicaragua from Costa Rica in 2010.

That year, the bodies of four adults and one child were found buried on the property of a hostel that Holbert owned.

Holbert killed a US citizen named Mike Brown, his wife and young son in 2007. Authorities have said that Brown may have been living under an alias and they don't know where he was from. In 2010, Holbert killed Cheryl Lynn Hughes, a native of St Louis, Missouri, who ran a small hotel in Panama, and Bo Icelar, former owner of a gallery in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

Holbert had left North Carolina after he went through a divorce to a previous wife, sold his landscaping business, and filed for bankruptcy. He met Reese in North Carolina.

In Montana, Holbert stole a car and sold it. Back in North Carolina, he sold a $200,000 home that he didn't own. Authorities pursued him across a half-dozen states that included a high-speed chase in Wyoming.

He and Reese had been living in Panama under the alias Cortez. They were fleeing a Panamanian investigation when they were arrested in Nicaragua.