Commentary November 16 2026

Editorial | ECJ and the voters’ list

3 min read

Loading article...

The Electoral Commission of Jamaica (ECJ) logo. The Electoral Commission of Jamaica (ECJ) logo.

Parliament may indeed have to provide the $9 billion the Electoral Office of Jamaica (EOJ) says it needs for a reverification of Jamaica’s voters’ list.

However, the legislature ought to know and should require the Electoral Commission of Jamaica (ECJ) – under which the EOJ falls – to tell Parliament if and why the system that is supposed to purge dead people from the register doesn’t work.

In that regard, the ECJ’s leadership, and its technical staff at the EOJ, must be among the stakeholders invited to make submissions to Parliament’s Human Resources and Social Development Committee (HRSCD), which is now reviewing Everald Warmington’s private member’s motions for a series of adjustments to the election laws.

Among Mr Warmington’s proposals is to extend the period for voting in elections by at least an hour, to 11 hours; that political party outdoor agents be allowed closer to where votes are being cast; and that the law permits ballots to be marked with symbols other than an ‘X’.

However, the number of people on Jamaica’s voters’ registers, currently at 2,090,343, has in recent years become a contentious issue, colouring debates over voter participation in elections and citizens’ attitude to the democratic process.

In Jamaica’s last general election, in September 2025, just under 40 per cent of an electorate of 2,077,800 cast ballots. The voter turnout was only slightly better than the 37.85 per cent for the 2020 vote, which was held in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. There were 1,913,410 people on the register for the 2020 poll.

DECLINING VOTER TURNOUT

Voter participation in those two elections continued a more than two-decade trend of declining turnouts, which most analysts link to growing disenchantment, especially among young people, with the island’s political parties and the functioning of Jamaica’s democracy.

However, some critics insist that even if there is disenchantment with domestic politics, its reflection by recorded participation in elections is exaggerated because of a bloated register, which has not been seriously reviewed or culled in decades.

For example, in debates over participation in last year’s parliamentary elections, former director of elections Orette Fisher estimated between 300,000 and half a million excess names were on the register. Put another way, Mr Fisher felt that the register had between 14 and 24 per cent more names than should be on it. If not the specific numbers, the contention of a bloated register is also held by the chairman of the HRSCD, Duane Smith.

If indeed there are that many excess names on the voters’ register, there is no widespread view that it distorts election outcomes. The Gleaner’s Editorial Board doesn’t hold that view.

People who vote in Jamaican elections have to produce special voter identification cards that carry their fingerprints, and in cases where those cards are lost or misplaced, voters have to swear or affirm their identities and provide biodata information that is checked against the records. In election cycles since the 2000s, there have been several close outcomes in which governments have been changed or retained without questions over the legitimacy of the administration.

The fundamental contention is over the impact on the analysis of the health of the island’s democracy.

STATISTICS NOT ACCURATE

“The voter turnout statistics that are always bandied about after an election are not accurate because every elected member here will tell you (that) when they go through their voters’ list they see their grandma on the list of blessed memory,” said Mr Smith, the HRSCD’s chairman. “We see people who migrated 10, 20 years ago still on the list. So we are not getting an accurate number.”

Under Jamaica’s registration system, new and eligible voters – once they reach the age of 18 – are always being added. An updated list is published every six months.

The system provides for the purging of names, according to an ECJ report to Parliament for 2016/17:

• quarterly reports of deaths from the Registrar General’s Department, as required by law;

• newspaper obituaries;

• funeral programmes;

• reports from persons in parliamentary constituencies;

• reports from political representatives in the constituencies;

• information from police stations across the island; and

• “any other credible source”.

“Continuous registration is the process of continually maintaining the voters’ list by adding the names of eligible voters, as well as deleting the names of those who no longer meet eligibility requirements, for example, the dead,” that ECJ report said. “This means there is no need to automatically conduct a full enumeration/registration each election period, as was the case in previous years.”

The system, however, does contemplate periodic reverification of the register. The Gleaner agrees that three decades is a long time between this being done. So, the intention by the current director of elections, Glasspole Brown, to request $9 billion in the coming fiscal year for such an exercise may not be unreasonable. Mr Smith has said that cost notwithstanding, it is necessary.

At the same time, the ECJ must explain why, if the list is excessively bloated, the system hasn’t worked as it was designed to perform; what mechanisms need improving; and where and how this is to be done.

After all, $9 billion is a big bill for taxpayers to shoulder.