Letter of the Day | The optics were right. Now let us dissect the argument.
Loading article...
THE EDITOR, Sir:
PM Andrew Holness chose his setting well. Before the party faithful, a polished presentation on Jamaica’s foreign policy could project scholarship, confidence, and command. The language was elevated. The sovereignty was emphatic. The applause was predictable.
But a party conference is a platform for persuasion. It cannot substitute for parliamentary scrutiny of decisions taken in Jamaica’s name.
The prime minister declared that Jamaica would not be co-opted into any single ideological agenda or grouping. In the fuller presentation, however, he anchored his position in a Western orientation, liberal democracy, and free markets. These are ideological commitments. They do not become neutral merely because he endorses them.
That is the first weakness in his argument. He risks presenting his opponents’ convictions as ideological baggage while dressing his own in the supposedly impartial language of practicality.
Michael Manley’s democratic socialism was an openly declared political philosophy. Its policies and consequences remain legitimate subjects of criticism. But Manley demonstrated that Jamaica could articulate a position and help shape an international agenda through Caribbean integration, opposition to apartheid, and advocacy for a fairer economic order.
Holness is entitled to a different philosophy. He is not entitled to dismiss conviction itself as evidence of captivity.
The second weakness concerns his invocation of the national interest. Investment, security, trade, and prosperity are legitimate objectives. Naming them does not establish that a particular decision advances them. A government must explain the connection between the concession it makes and the benefit Jamaicans receive.
Consider Cuba. Jamaica’s abstention on the United Nations embargo resolution marked a departure from its longstanding voting position. The Government denies that US pressure determined its decision. That denial must be assessed alongside its explanation of what the change achieved.
How did abstention improve the prospects of ending Cuban suffering? How did it strengthen Jamaica’s sovereignty? What diplomatic opportunity did it create that a vote against the embargo would have prevented?
These are questions for an accountable government. They cannot be answered by suggesting that critics are prisoners of outdated rhetoric.
Jamaicans understand unequal power. A small, dependent country does not negotiate with Washington on equal terms. A government may sometimes accept an unwelcome concession because it fears the alternatives. But then, level with us. Explain the constraint. Identify the sacrifice. Show how the decision protects Jamaica.
O. Dave Allen