House Speaker insists marriage to PM does not compromise her independence, defends her leadership
Loading article...
Amid renewed scrutiny over her stewardship of Parliament, Speaker of the House of Representatives Juliet Holness sought to make clear that her marriage to Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness neither compromises her independence nor accounts for her appointment to the post.
During her opening remarks at today's sitting of Parliament, Holness said that although she generally allowed her service to speak for itself, the constitutional position deserved to be made clear.
She pointed out that she is a third-term Member of Parliament for East Rural St Andrew, representing her constituents in the House.
“The mandate is mine in my own right, neither conferred nor diminished by my marriage,” she said.
She also pointed to Section 43 of the Constitution, which outlines the eligibility and election criteria for House Speaker.
“I was duly elected to this chair and my marriage is neither a constitutional disqualification nor a measure of my independence or judgment,” she said to applause from some members.
Holness was elected Speaker in 2023. However, her tenure has been plagued by controversy, with Opposition members voicing concerns about a conflict of interest because of her marriage to the Prime Minister.
There have also been mounting tensions between Government and Opposition legislators over the conduct of House proceedings.
During the last parliamentary sitting on November 3, a heated confrontation broke out following the adjournment of the sitting.
Holness had abruptly ended a debate on an Opposition motion to censure the Government for abstaining on a vote at the United Nations calling on the United States to end its more than six-decade-old economic embargo on Cuba, soon after it commenced.
Manchester North Western MP Mikael Phillips verbally confronted Holness.
The exchange escalated into a war of words between Phillips and Western Kingston MP Desmond McKenzie, with expletives heard during the confrontation.
The quarrel was broadcast live and subsequently circulated widely across traditional and social media.
Phillips later apologised, explaining that he reacted after McKenzie made derogatory comments about his late mother.
However, McKenzie has insisted that he has no reason to apologise.
The incident also sparked varying accounts from other members involved in the parliamentary fracas, with Holness alleging that Opposition MP Dr Angela Brown Burke physically assaulted her and denying that she had turned off microphones.
Brown Burke has denied those allegations and has called for Holness to retract her statement.
Meanwhile, asserting that the strength of Parliament is not just about the authority it exercises, but also the principles it upholds and the standards it maintains, Holness said that while robust debate and principled disagreement are essential to democracy, neither protests nor disagreement justifies disorder, obstruction or defiance of the chair.
Further, she said any disagreements with her rulings are matters of parliamentary procedure and should be assessed against the Standing Orders, not her personal relationship.
“I stand by the rulings I have made, and the procedures grounded upon which they were given. Members are entitled to challenge decisions through the appropriate parliamentary processes, but there is a clear distinction between legitimate scrutiny and personal attacks or intimidation intended to undermine the office holder,” she said.
In a letter to Holness shared with the media today, Leader of Opposition Business Phillip Paulwell objected to the Speaker using her opening remarks “to make negative or disparaging remarks about elected members of the Chamber or the Opposition as a whole”.
Paulwell said that such comments are not allowed by the Standing Orders that govern parliamentary proceedings.
He said that when such remarks are made, the Opposition will continue to insist that the affected member or members have the right to reply.
In an apparent response to the letter, Holness said the practice of Speakers addressing the House on matters concerning its proceedings and institutional responsibilities is long-standing, and she will continue to exercise that responsibility within the rules of the House.
“Disagreements with the chair do not render its statements improper, nor should it become a demand by any member for silence,” she said.
“Let me be equally clear, I will not be intimidated into silence or pressured into abandoning my responsibilities.”
She further committed to discharging the duties of her office with fairness, firmness and impartiality, and to respecting the rights of each member while upholding the authority of the chair.
Holness left the chair after her remarks, and the parliamentary proceedings were overseen by Deputy Speaker Heroy Clarke.
The Gleaner was informed that Mrs Holness and other Government members participated in a march to show support for her leadership.
- Sashana Small
Follow The Gleaner on X, formerly Twitter, and Instagram @JamaicaGleaner and on Facebook @GleanerJamaica. Send us a message on WhatsApp at 1-876-499-0169 or email us at onlinefeedback@gleanerjm.com or editors@gleanerjm.com.