Sports November 18 2026

Lopsided races shoot simulcast plans in the foot

2 min read

Loading article...

GIVE ME LIBERTY, ridden by Christopher Mamdeen, wins the fifth running of the ALSAFRA Trophy over seven-and-a-half furlongs at Caymanas Park on Sunday. GIVE ME LIBERTY, ridden by Christopher Mamdeen, wins the fifth running of the ALSAFRA Trophy over seven-and-a-half furlongs at Caymanas Park on Sunday. Photo - Anthony Minott/Freelance Photographer

Caymanas Park’s hopes of becoming a boutique simulcast racetrack, attractive to horseplayers internationally, get no favours from payouts such as last weekend’s — meagre returns, especially on exotic bets — primarily the result of ready-made favourites, horses who have no business competing against inferior opposition.

Wildly popular in North America, inter-tote wagering and simulcasts are key income-earners for big and small tracks alike. Whereas the New York circuit, Florida, Kentucky and California racetracks are much-sought-after products by smaller tracks for the quality of their racing, boutique circuits with competitive betting and good field sizes do hold their own whenever the bigger venues are on off-days.

No bettor likes to look at a race programme and be able to readily identify up to four events with favourites not worth second-guessing. Apart from the financial lure, horse racing’s biggest draw is the challenge of being able to choose a likely winner from a competitive field of runners, hoping fellow bettors would miss the tiny detail that could make the difference between winning and losing.

Any racetrack that develops a reputation of being a home for ‘chalks’, prohibitive favourites, the kind that has even the most seasoned punter wondering whether a day at the beach would be better spent, is shooting itself in the foot by way of having all the ingredients (horses and a captive public) but missing equitable and competitive racing.

After years spent trying to explain that claiming and conditions was a system devised for North America, a region which, at one point, had 314 racetracks, it is ironic that many local horsemen are now starting to feel the effects, especially with the advent of foreigners being imported for the Mouttet Mile.

Superior foreigners brought in for the Mouttet Mile, multiple winners, are being allowed to start their local careers in open allowance with no regard for quality of race won overseas. Equally talented imported maidens are allowed to debut among local-breds, non-winners of two races, many of whom will not win a second race until reaching age four or five. Why aren’t imported maiden horses debuting among non-winners of an overnight allowance?

Imported runners will certainly not all be of equal or similar ability. However, all overseas winners should go straight to grade one with topweight, allowing their performances to determine whether they are capable of holding their own among the best horses in the country.

Take GIVE ME LIBERTY, GALLANT GROOM and THE PRINCE’S SPUR, three runners imported for the Mouttet Mile with overseas victories under their girths. Take note of bettors’ skepticism when THE PRINCE’S SPUR’s connections made him skip class to debut in the grade one Gold Cup.

It will only be a matter of time before better horses are brought in for the Mouttet Mile, making it even more difficult for local-breds to have any chance of winning a race from as low as non-winners of two races through three, four, restricted company, overnight allowance, open allowance and grade one.

Imported horses have certainly fulfilled their roles of supplementing racecards but should not be made to face weak local rivals. Imported maidens should be starting their careers among non-winners of an overnight allowance, quickly ascending to grade two and eventually top-tier grade one.

Local-breds, in the main, are no match for foreigners, who are being given the benefit of the doubt, both maidens and winners. How can such a system provide competitive and attractive betting to the overseas market, which has many options to choose from?

Let’s not even start talking about DODGE THIS LINK, claimed for $350,000 dropped to $200,000, closing Sunday’s Reggae 6 as a 1-9 favourite. Why should a horse at what should be the most unpredictable level of racing, bottom-of-the-barrel claiming, go off at odds befitting an undefeated three-year-old derby winner facing maidens all over again?

Kick me if that catches the fancy of an overseas bettor with multiple tracks to choose from.