Jalil Dabdoub | “If it ain’t broke, why fix it?”
Loading article...
A political commentator posted on X recently describing Jamaica as the oldest uninterrupted Black-majority sovereign democracy in history, having maintained constitutional parliamentary government since Independence in 1962. Why tamper with such a successful system? The conclusion was: “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”
It is an appealing argument, but it begs a more fundamental question: Have we become so comfortable with the institutions we inherited that we have lost sight of the nation we ought to be building?
Jamaica has debated constitutional reform for decades, identifying provisions requiring amendment and institutions needing strengthening. Yet, perhaps what has been missing from this process is not simply the political will to reform our Constitution, but a clearly articulated national philosophy and vision to guide that reform.
The argument that an enduring system should be left untouched is fundamentally flawed. Survival and stability are not necessarily progress, and the absence of systemic failure is hardly the highest standard by which a nation should measure its democratic achievements.
Jamaica has much to be proud of. Governments have changed through the ballot box, and political disagreements have largely been resolved within our constitutional framework. But preserving our democracy and realising its full potential are two very different things.
Democracy is more than elections. Its true test is not simply how it functions when those entrusted with power are responsible and principled, but how effectively it protects the country when they are not. A Constitution must anticipate political excess, guard against the concentration of power, and provide meaningful remedies when authority is abused. Its effectiveness must never depend solely on the goodwill of those who govern.
No Constitution can compensate for poor leadership or political dishonesty. Likewise, good leadership cannot indefinitely compensate for inadequate institutional safeguards. We must therefore examine the independence of oversight institutions, political accountability, access to justice, and citizens’ ability to influence decisions affecting their lives. Rights mean little if citizens cannot afford to enforce them or delays render remedies meaningless.
CHALLENGE
But our challenge extends beyond identifying which constitutional provisions should change. It is determining what kind of country Jamaica wishes to become and what principles should govern the exercise of state power. We have spent decades debating the mechanics of government, but have we sufficiently considered the national purpose that machinery is intended to serve?
A national philosophy is an understanding of the principles upon which our society should be structured, the relationship between the State and its citizens, and the responsibilities we owe one another. It should frame our national priorities and the standards by which we measure progress. Economic growth cannot be the sole measure of national achievement if its benefits remain beyond the reach of large sections of our population. Political stability alone cannot define democratic success if political leaders cannot be meaningfully held to account. A nation must know not only what it wishes to achieve, but what it stands for.
Emancipation, universal adult suffrage and Independence were expressions of our struggle for freedom, dignity, equality and self-determination. Independence in 1962 gave us political sovereignty and the responsibility to determine our own destiny. But Independence could never have been the completion of the nation-building project. As we look towards the future, we must ask what kind of Jamaica we intend to leave behind. What opportunities should exist for a child born into poverty? What inequalities should we have overcome? What inheritance are we preparing for the unborn?
This is where constitutional reform assumes its greater significance. It is not simply about changing institutions or provisions; it is about strengthening our sovereignty and giving practical expression to the principles by which we as a people wish to govern ourselves. Our national philosophy should provide the compass; our Constitution, laws and institutions, should provide the framework through which we pursue that vision.
COMPLETING POLITICAL INDEPENDENCE
Republican status represents an important part of completing our political independence. Adopting the Caribbean Court of Justice as our final appellate court speaks to judicial sovereignty and confidence in our own regional institutions. Stronger parliamentary oversight concerns the distribution and accountability of power. These are important elements of our constitutional conversation, but the choices we make must ultimately be informed by a broader understanding of the nation we wish to build and the principles by which we wish to govern ourselves.
This conversation cannot belong exclusively to political parties or be reduced to negotiations between Government and Opposition. The Constitution belongs to the Jamaican people. Businesses, professional organisations, academia, the media and citizens must have a meaningful opportunity to help define our national aspirations. Nor should articulating a national philosophy become an excuse for postponing necessary constitutional reform. Both processes must inform and reinforce each other.
We should defend our democratic inheritance, but genuine respect for it requires the confidence to acknowledge its shortcomings and the courage to address them. “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” may be a convenient argument for preserving what exists, but it is a dangerous philosophy for a nation still engaged in the unfinished business of nation-building. We cannot allow preservation of the status quo to become a national ambition.
A Constitution must be more than a record of a nation’s survival; it must give expression to its aspirations. Our responsibility is not simply to preserve the Jamaica we inherited, but to imagine a better one and build the institutions capable of realising that vision. Nation-building did not end at Independence, and constitutional reform is not an end in itself. It is part of our continuing journey towards a more perfect nation. We owe that responsibility to ourselves, to those who came before us and, above all, to those yet to come.
Are we building the Jamaica we aspire to become, or simply maintaining the Jamaica we already have?
Jalil Dabdoub is an attorney at law. Send feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com